Evaluation of the STIRData Platform

The STIRData platform comprises a collection of tools and methodologies designed to establish interoperability among business-related datasets. Its purpose is to aid data owners, publishers, and users in sharing machine-readable and semantically meaningful data.

At its core, the platform adheres to the STIRData specification, which outlines standards for the representation, exchange, and transformation of business data. The STIRData project introduces two key outcomes open for evaluation:

  • A linked data architecture enabling business registries to maintain data locally.
  • The STIRData portal, which empowers users to access open company data.

To assess the project's efficacy, two evaluation questionnaires were devised – one for the portal and another for the architecture. A diverse set of 30 evaluators, including Experts, ECG Group, members of the European Commission's SEMIC team, and regular users, participated. Findings highlighted the STIRData platform's significance in promoting data interoperability.

statisticcs-page

STIRData Statistics Page

explore-page

STIRData Explore Page

Strengths

  • Based on a widely accepted and well-defined specification: The STIRData specification is based on the W3C Semantic Web standards, which are widely accepted by the data community. This makes it easier for data owners, publishers, and re-users to understand and use the platform.
  • Offers a comprehensive toolset aligned with the specification: The STIRData platform provides a comprehensive set of tools that can be used to implement the STIRData specification. These tools include a data modeling tool, a data transformation tool, and a data publishing tool.
  • Boasts user-friendliness: The STIRData platform is designed to be user-friendly. The tools are easy to use and the documentation is clear and concise. This makes it easy for users of all levels of experience to get started with the platform.
  • Adheres to open-source principles: The STIRData platform is open source, which means that it is freely available to use and modify. This allows users to customize the platform to meet their specific needs.

Weaknesses

  • The current distributed architecture exhibits immaturity, leading to performance concerns: The STIRData platform uses a distributed architecture, which means that the data is stored on multiple servers. This can lead to performance problems, especially when the data is large or complex. The platform is still under development, and the distributed architecture is not yet fully mature. This can lead to performance problems, such as slow query response times.
  • Some users may find its utilization complex: The STIRData platform can be complex to use, especially for users who are not familiar with the STIRData specification. The platform uses a number of technical terms and concepts, which can be difficult to understand for some users.
  • Effective usage mandates a certain level of technical proficiency: The STIRData platform requires a certain level of technical proficiency to use effectively. This can be a barrier to adoption for some users who do not have the necessary skills. The platform uses a number of technical tools and concepts, which can be difficult to learn for some users.

Conclusions

In sum, the STIRData platform emerges as a valuable resource for enhancing business data interoperability. It simplifies usage and supplies robust tools for realizing the STIRData specification. Nonetheless, it's worth noting that ongoing development is necessary, as certain tools remain in an evolving stage.

Suggestions for Enhancing the STIRData Platform:

  • Bolster tool development, prioritizing user-friendliness.
  • Augment documentation and training materials to ease user onboarding.
  • Expand outreach efforts to encompass a wider audience of data stakeholders.

The STIRData platform possesses the potential to significantly enhance business data interoperability. By advancing its capabilities and accessibility, it can play a pivotal role in fostering data sharing and reuse across organizational and geographical boundaries.